To find the best stocking stuffers for your girlfriend, first see if the gift checks off one of these boxes — something stylish, something silly, or something sweet. You know your girl. Would she most like something on the glam side? Or is the way to her heart through some adorably funny gift? Or does she wear her heart on her sleeve and appreciate sentimental gifts the most?

You know your girlfriend likes her makeup, as it takes about an hour to get out the door. Know that all lipsticks are not created equal. So do a little snooping into her makeup stash. Note brands and colors, and then pick up a few extras of her favorites to surprise in the stocking. She’ll be impressed that you got the details just right.

When you have no clue where to begin in the gift hunt (or really want to surprise her this year), seek the support of her best friends. They’ll know what little stocking stuffer would supremely delight her. They’ll know where to find it, too. You’ll also score points with the besties for thinking ahead and caring about finding something special for your girl.

Think about when your girlfriend is on the go. Does she commute far to work? Does she travel by train? Is she a frequent flyer? Travel accessories are going to be just the right size for a stocking — small and compact. Pick up her favorite toiletries in travel size or score some small travel accessory she could use (headset?) and you’ll be set.

What is your girlfriend’s favorite shop? Is there one store in the mall that is her must-go place every time? Head there for some gift inspiration. Often around the holidays, stores will have an area around the checkout counter that’s stocked with stocking stuffer gifts. You’ll know you’re in just the right place to choose a gift that’s just her style.

Browse a Valentine’s search on Pinterest for endless inspiration for small gifts that play on a pun or cute message. You know she’s a sucker for that sweet stuff. For example, you could play off the message of “warming her up” with a set of hand warmers stuffed in her stocking (note attached).

Diamonds aren’t the only gems that are a girl’s best friend. Look for casual earrings or a necklace that add a tiny sparkle to her holiday, without busting the stocking stuffer budget. First take a sneak peek in her jewelry box to get ideas on what style of everyday jewelry she likes to wear (rose gold or silver? Big statements or small and shiny?)

Here’s inspiration to catch her attention:

A Sappy Guide to Romantic Gift Ideas for Your Girlfriend

A Romantic's Guide to Swoon-Worthy Valentine Gift Ideas for Her

How to Book an Experience Gift They’ll Remember