She’s special and you know it, but you’re still wanting to keep things casual for now. How do you show her that you care without leading her on to think that you want more than is already happening? If you don’t want her to think that you see a long-term future with her, you’ve got to stick with traditional, generic, and practical gifts. Definitely DO NOT give her anything in a ring or jewelry box...no jewelry at all. Seriously. Don’t torture her. And definitely do not spend a lot of money on your gift. Chocolates or a gift that is practical for her to use but also colored red or pink (a la Valentine’s Day) is a good call. Headphones for hitting the gym, a travel mug for her commute, you get the point. Oh and, avoid gifts that relate to her spending the night, too.